I found this chapter to be the most grounded in practical, immediate application so far. I certainly related to Palmer's own "good" class - "bad" class paradox. As mentioned before, I once taught two sections of the same class with completely different results (same materials, syllabus . . . .). Reading the evaluations by the students of the two sections revealed two glaringly different perspectives: 1) I was the greatest teacher ever or 2) I stunk. A true paradox in teaching. Unlike Palmer, I didn't reflect at all on what I learned from the evaluations from the "bad" class. Sad to say, I simply ignored those and glowed in the positive reviews.
For me, beyond that, one of the greatest paradoxes which I have found in teaching is the one in which we as teachers must teach the class as a whole -- cover "X" amount of materials in a certain time versus reaching, somehow touching, the inner knowledge and anima of each inidividual student. This is a continual quandry.
I also found the last section of the chapter most salient. I recall teaching (in a situation as Palmer observed), when I asked a question, waited for a response, got none and jumped in trying to "remedy" the silence, only to
sink further in pedagogical muck. From this example Palmer concludes with the need for higher self to cope.
I think herein lies the most relevant comments for teaching in Catholic schools. His reflections on endurance vis-a-vis suffering stemming from the "tension of opposites" -- actively embracing of it -- is most profound. To make sense of suffering is one of central tennents of Catholicism. As Paul writes on suffering in Romans, 5: 3-5: "[W]e also rejoice in our sufferings, because we know that suffering produces perserverance; perserverance, character, and character, hope. And hope does not dissappoint us, because God has poured out his love into our hearts by the Holy Spirit, whom he has given us."
I have this week's assignment of the teaching experience for this Chapter. The reflections I would ask of you in preparation for this are: share in the next class 1) one passage or example from Scriptures, etc., on suffering/one that you might use or emphasize in class and 2) an example, not mentioned before, of a significant paradox you have found in your own teaching. Thanks!
Monday, October 19, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

There must be a dominant personality trait that responds one way or the other to praise/criticism. I've always been of the mindset that I'll remember -probably forever - the one critical thought/comment amidst a flurry of positive reviews. (My favorite quote from high school was, "Don't worry, boys. We'll weather this storm of approval and come out hated as ever.") Palmer touched on some fundamental and intuitive truths. I, too, found much practical usage with this chapter and appreciate your quote of Paul. Thanks for the heads up for Thursday.
ReplyDeleteWow Carla!
ReplyDeleteWhat a perfect quote for this chapter. I wonder if there's another passage of scripture that could fit any better with this weeks subject matter.
I'm starting to understand how letting "suffering" occur in our classrooms in effect successfully brings together the paradox of teaching and learning Palmer spoke of in the chapter.
Words of power from Paul from Carla.
ReplyDelete